Are the US anthem and “Khasbulat the daring” the same tune?


19/01/2022
They write that the melody of the US national anthem is completely torn off from the Russian song “Khasbulat Udaloy”. Its author was the English composer John Stafford Smith, who in 1780 wrote for the London club “Anacreontic Society”; hymn “To Anacreon in Heaven”. Composition “The Star-Spangled Banner” by that time it was already an anthem. Expert answer 0 + –

Responding Candidate of Historical Sciences Alexander Bayramov:
– Indeed, these melodies are very similar. The US Navy adopted it as an anthem a long time ago. How to understand this? Источник aif.ru And the Americans just stole the melody. Either a bus, or a vision. True, not the state, but the fleet. But there is one catch. Another thing is that the Americans whistled the melody of their anthem. So, according to all formal signs, it turns out that ours managed to do it earlier, and significantly. Moreover, the composition “The Star-Spangled Banner”, i.e. Indeed, one on one! When will the modernization of public transport reach cities and villages? At the same time, the song was first performed in Baltimore. Weekly “Arguments and Facts” No. 03. The words were taken from the poem “The Defense of Fort McHenry”, written in 1814. And the poem of the poet, officer and veteran of the Caucasian War Alexander Ammosov, which formed the basis of the song about Khasbulat, appeared in print in 1858
The music was adapted to it in 1890. “The Banner Spangled with Stars”, officially became the anthem of the United States in 1931. Apparently, both Americans and Russians musical inspiration was drawn from one source. In this hymn, a promise was made to the ancient Greek poet Anacreon, who above all put good wine, a friendly feast and the love of beautiful women, to follow his precepts.